New Progressive?

When I was young during the Vietnam war I readily joined in on the large Boston Common demonstrations. Now I'd rather chat up a neighbor who disagrees with me, at least initially.

I once worked for a miserable left leaning telemarketing company in Cambridge that had a client roster of things like the Sierra Club and the National Parks Conservation Association. While many of the people I pestered were excited about volunteering their time in lieu of a check, these organizations were flatly useless at harnessing this genuine human urge to do something more personal than writing a check.

These seem to describe the two main things the old progressives actually do, march in increasingly ineffectual demonstrations that make caricatures of participants and write checks.

Yes there are many other personal things done by many and this seems to be on the rise. The Obama campaign has given an unprecedented chance to do something beyond waving a placard or writing a check and the value of these in kind kindness contributions more than equals the cash flow as an offset and may be adding other inputs like detailed knowledge of the on the ground conditions that can't be bought at any price.

I am excited to see the presence of Al Giordano online in an ultra pragmatic and fun site called The Field. I was a whistle blower years ago, 1995, I think. I was working at another polling outfit that was testing the water for a horrific John Silber, Reagan's "favorite Democrat". Silber's tenure at Boston University was marked by steady vindictiveness and arrogance and since my relatives helped to found the place, it was personal. The test poll outcome was hilarious and not good for Mr. Silber. Citizens of the Commonwealth generally indicated that Silber might have a shot if Heinrich Himmler was the opponent. Otherwise, forget it. The poll was badly constructed and revealed over its course that Silber commissioned it, dumb move.

After my shift ended I went back to Hoffman's house, where I was living and mentioned it to Andrew, son of Abbie, and he immediately called Al up and had me spill the beans. The timing fit the deadline of the Boston Phoenix, where Al worked, and he got a cool little scoop out of it that infuriated Silber while ensuring that he would no longer be a candidate, fun stuff.

One of the reasons I like the Field is that Al left the Phoenix and wandered for a few years because he grew as dissatisfied with the fossilized caricature of the progressive as I was and he is thinking and writing well about what it could become. Now we both find ourselves confronted by a mess stressed world where a centered pragmatist, Senator Obama is actually making it happen.

So as this newborn takes shape, I find myself wondering what elements it might incorporate and here are a few that occur to me.

1. Breaking down the Walls of 'like mindedness'. To me, all you have to do for me to like, care about and help you is to be kind, honest and have some interest in a less toxic world, however you express it. You don't have to agree with me. This mawkish insecurity about agreement is one of the more sophomoric features of the American social landscape and it suggests a lack of self confidence, of worshiping at an altar of fear.

2. Sustainable living. Given the encroachment of Climate change, carbon footprint reduction should have a huge priority for all committed Neo Progressives. It an is immediate personal impact contribution and is far more useful than merely loving the living world, which should be a given.

3. Personal economics. One should seek to incorporate a clear understanding of economic forces and how they drive political outcomes. The corporate plutocracy is very vulnerable to loss from a growing refusal to buy their goods and services. You vote with your purchases as much as you vote in elections. Think through the allocations you make for stuff very carefully, not as a boycott so much as an ongoing approach to how your hard earned money is used for your benefit or your undermining.

These are a few items and it would be great for comment makers to add their idea of what this new transformation could be. I am not here to give short shrift to all the foundation values held by old progressives such as social justice, equal rights and a helpful role from governance to benefit the average person rather than a weighting toward malevolent plutocracy. We are in a time where the foundation needs new walls and a better roof.

Update: I noticed the auto formatting doesn't agree well with Google Document so here is the basic url for The field,http://narcosphere.narconews.com/thefield/

Display:


Bingo! (2.00 / 2)

march in increasingly ineffectual demonstrations that make caricatures of participants

This is a core complaint I have had with my Boomer peers and the culture we have created. Non-conforming as a personal statement against flaws in established society has become Conforming Non-Conformence to a new Established Society.  It does not require any personal reflection and stretching of the imagination to march against Globalization and chalk up a set of signs against Evil Capitalism - in fact it is a sure-fire way to be seen as Hip and Political, to conform with a set of peers and probably get yourself laid.  So I want to second (1), underline it, and put it in Bold Caps.

4. Search for Solutions.  It is my frustrating role to have endless conversations with my blue colleagues in which the other voices tie a series of worldly woes into a knot of hopelessness.  Well-worn memes about the failings of this country, of this culture, and of this world laid out in an insoluble maze of dead-ends and tiger traps, to the point that any suggestion of a new direction is answered with a stock example of another failure.  New Blue should not be about why nothing can be done, it should be about suggesting what might work.

So New Blue to me is about thinking for yourself, and seaching for workable solutions.  The fact that its most visible representative - Sen. Barack Obama - is shat upon by the Right for being optimistic, and often by the Left for pragmatic, makes him even moreso fit for the role.


Motley Moose: Progress Through Politics
by chrisblask on Sun Aug 10, 2008 at 11:55:16 AM EST

Re: New Progressive? (2.00 / 2)

Thanks. Very thoughtful diary.  

As a boomer (I guess - since I was born in 1947) from the old left, some of my old friends are about to take away my pc card - since my favorite word is "pragmatism".  They are voting Green, voting Nader, not voting as a protest, writing in _____ (name a leftist).

Others want Obama to be the second coming of Malcolm/Martin/Fred Hampton/Che Guevara.  A few have even more bizarre expectations.  

None of them seems to have a grip on reality.

The list of plaints from them is long.

Obama is not black enough
Obama is not left enough
Obama isn't loud enough
Obama isn't militant enough

yadda yadda yadda.

How they could ever expect him to be elected POTUS  if he adopted even 1/8 of their positions (not that they ever organize anything but they do have cool tee-shirts) is beyond me.

I've gotten to the point that I'd rather talk to the local farmers here about goats than have "political discussions" with my peers.

Anyway, I've ranted enough - thanks for letting me share. :)


Anthropologists for human diversity; opposing racism,sexism,homophobism, ageism and ethnocentrism.
by NeciVelez on Sun Aug 10, 2008 at 05:56:22 PM EST

Re: New Progressive? (2.00 / 2)

Thanks both of you. It is a discussion that needs to happen and I would love to see some open minded thoughtfulness instead of the usual reflexive jerking of knees.

I have been evolving a theory of generational archetype formation using the entire 20th century as my lab.

Allow me with some trepidation to describe the generational archetype correlations with feminism going back to Boomer.

Boomer feminists such as Ms Steinem were breaking new ground and theirs was a bit tentative but reasonably certain. They were to do a bit of boat rocking to make their points and gains but they weren't about to sink the thing and hadn't transformed it into a sense of entitlement.This is Hillary's world and it is a core aspect of her like-ability and genuine quality.

Gen X feminists conflated toughness with meanness and loved Andrea Dworkin. It was all outrage all the time and they were masters at the art of scolding.

I've been getting scolded by this cohort in many places for the past 27 years. They are hitting their early forties and I wonder how this shrill outlook will impact their sunset years. Will they go apoplectic? They also are big on entitlement.

Will Alzheimer's get them? Lord knows I have tried to like them and am helping a more harmless one right now who I adore.

Gen Y feminists are more confident and the first beneficiaries of the struggles of the preceding generations. They run with the benefits and focus on actual useful activity with grace and aplomb. Susan Faludi and Naomi Wolf seem to be their inspirations and mine as well.

Then we have the Millennials and boy are they exciting. These are a core of the Obama base.

For the first time I am seeing the complete pendulum swing from the Boomer Narcissism back to the Stewardship model Ms Faludi ascribed to those old magnificent World War Two people.

The Millennial outlook seems to have been shaped by the utter ugliness of the Cheney/Bush horror just as the World War Two outlook was shaped by the depression.It is a hopeful time on many levels and ye who would worship at the altar of despair may find yourself left behind.


by chris rich on Sun Aug 10, 2008 at 06:46:36 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.